I’ve been reflecting on how all the LLM-related events make me feel, and there seems to be a particular type of life experiences that I’m drawing on to process this. For me, this is an experience of living and growing up in a dictatorship — not a unique analogy, apparently, I’ve heard a number of my friends and acquaintances saying that it feels like they’re “a bit more prepared”. Another is the fact that as a teenager, I was groomed and abused by a mentor figure. These comparisons might seem extreme to some, but a certain common denominator here is institutional betrayal. The systems that I relied upon or were supposed to rely upon have failed me. Again, it seems.
I have not used LLMs to solve research problems for me, and after the Navier–Stokes incident I have stopped using them entirely, even for proofreading. Mostly because of the ethical concerns: I felt like there are so many underlying problems, having to do with environmental damage, privacy issues, plagiarism, deskilling, rushing the influx of new results at the expense of the youngest and most vulnerable, lending the credibility of our community to bad actors, etc, that the ends just don’t justify the means. There are many discussions in the community on how we should change our policies to reflect the new reality, and I feel like most of them have a weird starting point. The debates on how to adapt to using LLMs are often not even touching upon many of these ethical issues and whether LLM use is even worth it in the first place. I am not saying that you should agree with an opinion like mine, but I wish more people would acknowledge that it exists and has some valid grounds. I wish the discussions on policies would start from the beginning, without glossing over the fact that we have not unanimously agreed that LLM use is a good thing, and with eyes open to the consequences. We are not discussing these consequences enough during conferences, public panels and workshops, and, on a personal level, it is very understandable why. To ask the question: “Could we be wrong about this?”, people need to be prepared for the possibility of a positive answer, and it is not easy to admit that what you’ve been doing could be harmful to others.
As for me, I am once again finding myself in a situation where a system I depend on is doing things that I do not agree with and/or that are hurting me, and is pushing me to go along or suffer consequences. In my particular case, the stakes are a bit higher than just not succeeding in building an academic career: my passport is weak, and it has an expiry date, and no one can tell for how much longer it will be possible to renew it without going back home. The sane thing to do would be getting an industry job in a country with an easy path to citizenship, and to work towards some actual safety and stability in life, without fear of being stranded in different visa spaces with my partner. But the thing is, we both love doing research, so we are going to fight for a little bit longer.
But what have I learned from these other experiences of institutional betrayals? Perhaps the second one is instructive. The institution in question was a summer school in competitive programming. At the moment when I’ve processed things enough to realise that something really wrong has happened, it seemed scary to put myself in opposition. This institution was a well-known and important piece in the system of “elite” education in Russia, I had just finished school, and quite a lot of people I had to deal with on a day-to-day basis at the university had some ties to the place. It seemed scary even to detach myself from that community, and I suppose it was somewhat expected that as a “graduate” of that summer school, I would go back to teach.
Instead, I went to teach at a different summer camp, a regional one, far from the capital, run by a different group of people. I’ve found that we share similar values; we all wanted to make education more accessible and safe. To my best knowledge, we were the first among competitive programming camps in Russia to establish a code of conduct for the teachers, and, in general, to have some kind of anti-harassment measures in place. This is something that I am proud of. Ten years later, I am still great friends with people I have worked with on that (I am married to one!), and they have been a much more supporting and uplifting community for me than the other one could have ever been.
What I mean to say is, choosing for myself has led me to a healthier and a more fulfilling path. Sometimes you need just a bit of courage to look slightly further than the system offers.
I’m realising now how much my vision of a successful academic career relied on the reputations of people and institutions, and I must admit that these reputations have now taken a hit. Looking at the pile of recent LLM-generated results, some of them from the literal embodiments of academic success, I can’t help but wonder if the definition of success presented to me by academia is a bit too narrow, and whether this strategy of achieving it is the example that I want to follow. It often seems like our competitive job market doesn’t leave much room for soul-searching: it was always such a rigid thing, do this and that to maximise your CV, or be left behind. Now, in the midst of the crisis of the credit system, soul-searching is the only thing that can get us through. I’m not sure I believe that the new norms will be less limiting than the old ones, or that they will be in place any time soon, so, perhaps, it is down to my own judgement. In fact, trusting my own judgement was the first step in surviving these other institutional betrayals, even though in the moment it always seemed counterintuitive as a survival strategy.
So maybe this could be the silver lining for the young people like myself: yes, the future is scary, we do not know what will happen, the senior people also have no idea, but the traditional careermaxxing looks more senseless now than ever, so maybe you can try to formulate for yourself what it is that you consider a meaningful and fulfilling academic career, and then follow that. There are personal risks to balance here, but my guess is that in reality, we have more agency in our future than certain companies would like us to believe, and more even than the old system suggested. Another thing that I learned from institutional betrayals is to not surrender that agency too early: even if some means of expressing it are eventually taken away, making that effort puts pressure on the power structure and drains its resources.
Will this thinking get me through this upheaval? Who knows. I am but one person, I can be wrong about things. Fortunately, I am prepared for the possibility of being wrong, because it won’t imply harm to others. I will add one more thing: most of the “adults” may have no idea how to deal with the crisis, but I bet that around you there are many people who have experienced some kind of a major threatening change in life, or are just used to fighting for their rights. So if you want advice, ask women, ask queer people, ask people with less geographical or financial luck, people with disabilities, and so on. They will all have different opinions, but at least these will be coming from experience.
